User:SiFi270/Analysis of Yuki and Mikuru's Relationship

Relationships are a subject of much debate in the Haruhi Suzumiya fandom, perhaps more so than in any other. Although there are arguments for several couplings within the SOS Brigade, one of which that is sadly overlooked is Yuki and Mikuru. In most of the fandom's preferred relationships, Kyon appears to form one half of the couple, the other half frequently being Haruhi or Yuki. I have debated with many of these people over the nature of these character's relationships, and at times have even lost sleep over the issue. You may say that I am taking this all too seriously, but I say: So what? You worry about what worries you, and I'll worry about what worries me. But without further adieu, I will analyse every moment of interaction between these two characters, and see what conclusion I reach. Remember that when you eliminate the impossible, whatever remains, no matter how improbably, must be the truth.

Book 1: The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya

 * When Mikuru is first introduced to the story, she is very hesitant to join the SOS Brigade, until she notices Yuki.

''Then it was as if she suddenly noticed the presence of Nagato Yuki. Her eyes grew large and showed some hesitation. A moment later, she sighed and whispered in a low voice: "I see... I understand." What did you understand? "I'll quit the Calligraphy Club, and join your club..."''

I've discussed this scene with many people, seeing how it is the first hint of a relationship between the two characters, and most of those people insist that Mikuru agreed to join simply because she recognised Yuki. There are many problems with this theory. However, Mikuru does not seem to recognise Haruhi, which is logical, because the two have never met until this point. It seems unlikely that Mikuru is putting on an act, as it is later established that she is a terrible actress, and in her nervous state she could easily have accidentally indicated that she knew Haruhi, causing her to become suspicious. Additionally, when Mikuru finally leaves the clubroom, she only begins to realize that this may have something to do with her mission, and even later on she admits that she didn't think Haruhi was capable of causing a time-quake. Also, Itsuki claims that the Aliens, Time-Travellers and Espers barely interacted with one another until Kyon's intervention. Combined with the fact that Yuki is just one of many Humanoid Interfaces, Mikuru would have no reason to recognise her at that point in time. If she was acting, however, then presumably she would also recognise Yuki, which does not explain her sudden change of plans upon seeing the girl.

What would SiFi do? If I were introduced to a new club, and I suddenly noticed somebody, that person alone wouldn't motivate me to join unless I was suddenly attracted to them.

Final Conclusion: Whatever Mikuru's original intentions, seeing Yuki obviously changed her mind. There is a name for this phenomenon: “Love at first sight”.


 * Later, when Kyon tries to explain to Mikuru that she doesn't have to join the Brigade, she declines.

"Besides, I'm interested in Nagato-san's presence..."

This is only moments after my first point, so Mikuru is most likely still oblivious to everybody's identities (Though she does begin to realize that it may have something to do with her mission.). If she was aware of their identities, wouldn't she realize that Haruhi was her main focus, and not Yuki?

What would SiFi do? If I knew everybody at the aforementioned club, I would probably be the most concerned the one who can manipulate reality to their whims. However, if there was somebody I was attracted to in the same club, I'd... well, I'd still be concerned about the reality-warper. But apparently Mikuru has a different idea of priorities to me. That's somewhat understandable.

Final Conclusion: Mikuru is either hoping that she will get to know Yuki better (Assuming she is oblivious at this point), or simply considers her to be more important than Haruhi (Assuming she is fully aware).


 * After Haruhi's finished changing Mikuru into her bunny-girl outfit, Yuki has a request for Kyon.

''"That." Nagato Yuki pointed on the ground. I looked and saw two sailor uniforms lying there... Erm, is that a bra I just saw? The short-haired, spectacled girl pointed at the cabinet on the other side of the room and then went back to reading her book. Couldn't you pick up the clothes yourself!? '' Kyon has a point. Why doesn't Yuki pick up the clothes herself? Normally, she wouldn't be at all bothered by a task like this.

What would SiFi do? If the clothes belonged to somebody I was attracted to, I would only touch them with that person's permission. If they simply belonged to a friend, I would flat-out refuse. But it's been shown that Yuki's not as picky as I am about things like that, so the former is more likely.

Final Conclusion: Yuki's either too nervous to pick up Mikuru's clothing, or she simply believes it would be disrespectful. However, the same argument could be used to prove that Yuki has feelings for Haruhi.


 * Throughout the series, Mikuru gets nervous around Yuki very often.

''After the opponent was changed, Asahina-san started to appear more anxious. I noticed Asahina-san's fingers started to tremble, and she wouldn't dare lift her head to look at Nagato. She would occasionally take a peek at Nagato and then look away quickly, which she did many times. In the end maybe Asahina-san couldn't really concentrate, so black quickly took a clear advantage in the game. How come? Asahina-san seems to be very wary of Nagato, I just don't understand why.''

I'm sure we all know how it feels in this position. You want to make your feelings known to someone, but whenever you're around them you can barely form a coherent sentence.

What would SiFi do? If I was attracted to someone, I would definitely become more nervous in their presence.

Final Conclusion: Mikuru is either nervous in Yuki's presence for reasons mentioned above, or she is simply afraid of her.